Do Gummy Vitamins Work? The Truth About Their Effectiveness and Benefits

Remember when taking your vitamins meant swallowing a horse pill or choking down a chalky tablet? Those days are long gone, thanks to the rise of gummy vitamins. These chewy, candy-like supplements have taken the health world by storm, promising all the benefits of traditional vitamins in a much more palatable package.

The 2023 CRN Consumer Survey shows that dietary supplements are mainstream, with 74% of U.S. adults taking them and 55% being regular users.

Gummy vitamins are exactly what they sound like – vitamins in gummy form. They're like the cool, hip cousins of those boring old pills. Packed with vitamins and minerals, these chewable supplements come in all sorts of fun shapes, colors, and flavors. From A to Zinc, you can find pretty much any nutrient wrapped up in these jiggly little morsels.

But, Do gummy vitamins work? And how do they stack up against their traditional counterparts? Well, that's what we're here to find out. So, grab a seat (and maybe a gummy vitamin or two), and let's answer the million-dollar question: Are gummy vitamins as effective as pills? Do they actually work, or are they just glorified candy?

Pros of Popping Gummies

Cons to Consider

Okay, it's not all rainbows and gummy bears. There are a few drawbacks to keep in mind:

• Sugar, Sugar: Some gummies come with a side of added sugars. Not ideal if you're watching your sugar intake.
• Dosage Dilemma: Getting the exact right amount of each nutrient in a gummy can be tricky. Quality matters here, folks.
• Too Much of a Good Thing: Because they taste so good, it's tempting to eat more than you should. Remember, they're vitamins, not actual candy!

In this video, Ali Rogin speaks with registered dietitian Shyla Davis-Cadogan about whether gummy vitamins work as effective as traditional vitamin pills.

Are gummy vitamins as effective as traditional vitamin pills? (Video Credit: PBS NewsHour)

Vitamin Gummies Benefits: More Than Just a Sugar Rush

Gummy vitamins aren’t just about making supplements fun (although that’s a huge win!). They bring some real benefits to the table, helping you get your nutrients without the hassle.

• Filling in the Gaps: Let’s face it, even the most health-conscious among us don’t hit all our nutritional targets every day. Whether it’s a busy lifestyle, picky eating habits, or dietary restrictions, gaps happen. Gummy vitamins offer a simple way to fill in those nutritional holes, ensuring you get essential vitamins and minerals even on your not-so-perfect days. It’s like having a safety net for your diet, catching the nutrients you might miss.
• Kid-Friendly and Senior-Approved: One of the biggest hurdles in taking supplements is the form they come in. For kids, vitamins often look like a dreaded chore. For seniors, large pills can be tough to swallow and even pose a choking hazard. Gummy vitamins flip the script—they’re approachable, enjoyable, and easy to consume. From toddlers who need a bit of coaxing to seniors who need something gentle, gummies make vitamins accessible for almost everyone.
• Absorption Station: Here’s something you might not know: some nutrients could be better absorbed when they come in gummy form. Certain vitamins, like vitamin D and certain B vitamins, might get a boost from the gummy format, which often includes ingredients that help your body break down and use those nutrients more efficiently. It's like giving your digestive system a friendly nudge, saying, "Go ahead, make the most of this!" That means you could be getting more out of your supplement than you would from a standard pill or tablet.

Advertisement

Why Might Gummy Vitamins Be Easier On The Stomach?

Gummy vitamins make supplements friendlier and more palatable to all, including children who do not like tablets and the elderly who can have trouble swallowing. They are pleasant and effortless to take.

In addition, gummies are easier on the tummy since they are made with sugars and chewy ingredients without any chalky and metallic flavor of certain pills. This reduces their chances of being uncomfortable, hence a sweet, easy alternative to chew your vitamins without the bitter taste and belly ache.

Myth Busting: Separating Fact from Fiction

Let's clear up some gummy gossip and set the record straight on a few misconceptions about these chewy supplements.

• Myth: Gummy vitamins don’t work as well as traditional pills or capsules.

Fact: As mentioned before, gummies go through the same manufacturing process as other supplements and contain the same active ingredients. The only difference is in their form and flavor. As long as you take them correctly, gummy vitamins can be just as effective as their traditional counterparts.

• Myth: Gummy vitamins are only for kids.

Fact: While kids gummies may seem like they're catered towards children with their fun shapes and flavors, they are suitable for adults too! Many adults find it easier to remember to take their vitamins when they are in gummy form, making them a convenient option.

• Myth: Gummy vitamins are just candy and have no nutritional value.

Fact: While it's true that some gummy vitamins may contain added sugars and artificial flavors, many reputable brands use natural sweeteners and flavors. Additionally, gummies do contain the same active ingredients as traditional pills or capsules, providing the same health benefits. So while they may taste like candy, they still serve a purpose for your overall health.

ALSO READ: Gummy Vitamins vs. Traditional Vitamins

Alex Evink, MS, RD

Alex Evink, MS, a Registered Dietitian boasting over 13 years of diverse experience, currently offers personalized nutrition counseling to patients with chronic kidney disease, aiming to slow its progression. She notes, “Vitamin supplementation can be ideal for individuals who are looking to fill in any nutritional gaps, or nutrients they may be missing from their diet. Gummy vitamins, specifically, are helpful to those who have difficulty swallowing pills. They can also help increase acceptance of supplements in young children because they usually taste really good!

Side Effects and Precautions

While gummy vitamins are generally safe, there are a few things you’ll want to keep on your radar to ensure you're taking them smartly and safely:

• Sugar Overdose: Many gummy vitamins contain added sugars to enhance taste, making them appealing but risky if overconsumed. One may think regular or overdose may boost vitamin levels but remember it will also add unnecessary sugars, leading to tooth decay, weight gain, and blood sugar issues, especially for those managing diabetes.
• Check for Allergens: If you have allergies, it’s crucial to scrutinize the ingredient list of any gummy vitamin you’re considering. Some might contain allergens like gelatin, gluten, or certain dyes. Fortunately, many brands are aware of these concerns and offer allergen-friendly options, but it’s always good to double-check.
• Stick to the Recommended Dose: More isn’t always better when it comes to vitamins. Taking too many could not only lead to mild side effects like nausea but, in some cases, could result in nutrient imbalances or toxicity, especially with fat-soluble vitamins like A, D, E, and K. Follow the recommended dosage, and you’ll be on the safe side.

• Moderation is Key: As tempting as it might be to eat gummies like candy (they do taste that good!), too many can lead to an upset stomach. Remember, gummy vitamins are still supplements and should be taken in recommended amounts. Overdoing it doesn’t mean you’ll get extra health benefits—just an unnecessary load on your digestive system.
• Supplement Labels: Learn to understand labels. They play an important role in understanding if the supplement is right for you. The label will have all information on Nutrition and Supplement fact label will have all information on what nutritions you will get, at what dosage and you can also find about added or total sugars.

The Shelf Life Question: Do Gummies Lose Their Potency?

Gummy vitamins do not have the same shelf life as traditional pills. They are highly receptive to heat, moisture, and air because of their chewy nature and may lose their potency after some time. To overcome this loss, manufacturers usually include additional nutrients at the beginning.

Yet by the time of storage months later, the real vitamin content might be less than the one that can be found on the label. This is indicated by clinging to each other or losing their fruity odor.

The best way to keep gummies fresh is to keep them in a dry and cool place and to check expiration dates.

Advertisement

Who Should Consider Gummy Vitamins?

Gummy vitamins can be a great fit for a variety of people, making them an inclusive option for almost anyone looking to supplement their diet:

• Kids Who Turn Their Noses Up at Traditional Vitamins: If you’ve ever tried to get a child to swallow a pill, you know it can be a battle. Gummy vitamins for kids make that task a whole lot easier. They look and taste like a treat, making kids more willing participants in their health journey.

ALSO READ: Are Gummy Vitamins Good for Kids?

• Seniors Who Have Trouble Swallowing Pills: As we age, the act of swallowing pills can become a real challenge, and in some cases, even a health risk. Gummy vitamins offer a soft, chewable alternative that’s easier on the throat and more appealing overall.
• Forgetful Folks: We’ve all been there—vitamins sitting on the shelf, collecting dust because they’re just not part of the daily routine. Gummy vitamins can change that. Their pleasant form and taste mean you’re more likely to remember them and actually look forward to taking them.
• Anyone Looking for a More Enjoyable Way to Get Their Daily Nutrients: Let’s be honest, a lot of us just want something that feels less like a task and more like a small treat. If that’s you, gummies might be the perfect solution, adding a bit of fun to your health regimen.

How to Choose a Good Gummy Vitamin?

Not all gummy vitamins are created equal, and finding the right one for you requires a bit of savvy shopping. Here’s what to look for:

• Reputable Brands with Good Reviews: A good reputation goes a long way. Look for brands that have positive feedback and a strong track record in the market. Check reviews from other users to see if they’ve had good experiences with the product.
• Low Sugar Content (or Sugar-Free Options): One of the biggest criticisms of gummy vitamins is their sugar content. While a little sugar isn’t a deal-breaker, opting for versions with minimal or no added sugars is a smart choice, especially if you’re watching your sugar intake or have conditions like diabetes.
• Clear Labeling of Ingredients and Nutritional Content: Transparency is key. Make sure the label clearly lists all ingredients and the exact amount of each nutrient. This helps you understand what you’re putting into your body and ensures you’re getting the dosage you need.
• Third-Party Testing for Quality Assurance: To ensure you’re getting what you pay for, choose brands that have their products tested by third-party labs. This extra step in quality assurance means the product has been verified for accuracy in nutrient content and safety, giving you peace of mind.